How we compare
How we compare with five other book makers
Choose us for a book drawn from your photos, for anyone, that you can read in full before paying. Choose Wonderbly or Hooray Heroes for a ready story made by people, Magic Story for a monthly book for a young child, and Lullaby or ToonyStory to write or steer the story yourself.
| Company | How a book is made | What you see before paying | Printed book, from | Digital copy | Who it is for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Once Upon My Story That is us | From your photos and a few lines we write a story about them and draw every page with AI | The whole book every page of a Quick book, free, with no card | $19.99 paperback, plus shipping from $5; hardcover $39.99 | $1.99 a PDF, and included with every printed book | Anyone partners, grandparents, friends, new parents and children |
| Choose us for a book about the people you name, drawn from your photos, that you read in full before paying. Studio (from $3.99) adds a choice of art style and 26, 34 or 42 pages, and you check the characters and story first. | |||||
| Wonderbly | A ready-written story chosen from its bookshop and personalized with a name, a character you pick and a dedication | The whole book “Preview the whole story before buying” | $39.99 softcover, the base price on each book (a 25% off code was running when we checked) | None listed formats are softcover, hardcover and layflat | Children and adults “personalized books for kids and adults” |
| Choose Wonderbly for a story by bestselling authors and illustrators, with no AI. | |||||
| Hooray Heroes | A ready-written story chosen from its catalog; you design each character’s look: hair, skin tone, eyes and more | Every page “Preview all the pages” | $29.99 softcover when we checked, shown beside a struck-through $49.99 | None listed cover options are soft or hard | Children, adults and pets “Personalized Books for Kids, Adults & Pets” |
| Choose Hooray Heroes to design each character’s look in detail, in a ready story made by people. | |||||
| Magic Story | From one photo of your child the photo becomes an illustrated character in a story you choose from its catalog | A scene or the cover “The preview does not show every page of the finished book.” | $44.99 hardcover, or $24.99 a month with its Magic Story+ subscription | None listed “Hardcover is the standard format” | Children aged 2 to 10 “made for children ages 2 to 10” |
| Choose Magic Story for a new hardcover every month for a child aged 2 to 10. | |||||
| Lullaby | A new story from your idea AI writes what you describe, or keeps your own text, and draws up to 5 people or pets from photos | Cover and 2 pages “the cover and the first 2 pages, before you pay anything” | $29.99 and up, after buying the $14.99 digital book (“Unlocks after purchasing the digital book”) | $14.99 per story, as a PDF and images | Children and grown-ups “couples, parents, grandparents, friends” |
| Choose Lullaby to write or direct the story yourself, edit every word and redraw any page. | |||||
| ToonyStory | A new story from your photos AI writes it from a theme or a template, or illustrates text you bring | The whole book “Previewing the whole book is free” | $16 softcover, plus shipping; hardcovers from $35 | Free, watermarked no watermark on plans from $9.99 a month ($7.99 billed yearly) | Anyone “Personalized storybooks for anyone you love” |
| Choose ToonyStory for a longer book, a choice of eight sizes or an animated video. | |||||
Looking for an alternative?
To Wonderbly
Wonderbly personalizes ready-written stories by its authors and illustrators; we write a new story about the people you name and draw them from your photos with AI. For a story by a known author and no AI, stay with Wonderbly.
To Magic Story
Magic Story draws one child into a story from its catalog and previews a scene or the cover; we draw anyone you name, a partner or a grandparent as well as a child, and you read every page of a Quick book first. For a new hardcover every month for a young child, stay with Magic Story.
Sources
Each company’s own pages, checked on . If something is out of date, write to hello@onceuponmystory.com and we will correct it.
- Wonderbly: Home page and its questions, A book page, When You Were Born, Help: How much are your books?
- Hooray Heroes: Home page, A book page, Courtney Becomes a Big Sister
- Magic Story: Home page and its questions, Help: How much does a book cost?, Help: Can I see a preview?
- Lullaby: Home page and its questions, Pricing page
- ToonyStory: Home page and its questions, Pricing page, Print a hardcover page
Wonderbly, Hooray Heroes, Magic Story, Lullaby and ToonyStory are names that belong to their owners, used here only to say who is who. We are not affiliated with any of them. Our own prices are on the prices page.
Questions people ask
Which is cheapest?
Going by the lowest printed price each site lists: ToonyStory $16 (softcover, plus shipping), ours $19.99 (paperback, plus shipping from $5), Hooray Heroes $29.99 (softcover when we checked, beside a struck-through $49.99), Lullaby $29.99 (after its $14.99 digital book), Wonderbly $39.99 (softcover) and Magic Story $44.99 (hardcover, or $24.99 a month by subscription).
For a digital copy, ToonyStory’s is free with a watermark, ours is $1.99 and Lullaby’s is $14.99.
Which lets me read the whole book before I pay?
We do: every page of a Quick book is free to read before you pay anything. So do Wonderbly, Hooray Heroes and ToonyStory. Lullaby shows the cover and 2 pages, and Magic Story shows a scene or the cover. A Studio book is paid for first, and you approve each character and read the story before any picture is drawn.
Are these books made with AI?
Ours are: we write the story and draw the pictures with AI. Wonderbly says its tales are by “bestselling authors and illustrators, never AI”. Hooray Heroes says “No AI - No Shortcuts”. Magic Story draws its characters from a photo and speaks of “generated avatars”. Lullaby says “both the story and illustrations are AI-generated”. ToonyStory calls itself “an AI-powered storybook creator”.
Who will star in yours?
About 2 minutes. Free.
About 10 minutes. From $3.99.
You sign in first so your book is saved.
